Casebook PBC Blog

What Is an Early Case Assessment?

Written by Trevor Norkey | Jan 15, 2024 11:00:00 AM
The prospect of litigation is a serious issue for your organization and can be overwhelming. Even with a clear mind, it can be challenging to see the complete picture, including available evidence, risks, and possible outcomes. This is why many human services organizations use early case assessments (ECA) to analyze and prepare for potential legal incidents. What Is Early Case Assessment (ECA)? Early case assessments evaluate a case's layers and potential outcomes to help you properly gauge the appropriate next steps. They measure the severity of a case compared to its defense and the potential costs of settlements compared to litigation losses. These assessments are usually performed before any litigation is filed when evidence is easiest to access. Effective ECA comprises multiple steps and evaluations, including: Analyzing relevant data from incident reports, case details, and other important files Assessing legal liability according to all applicable laws and agreements Compiling all potential costs, including settlement options, damages, and legal fees Comparing current cases to similar cases' results Connecting with specialized legal teams While some lawyers perform the entire ECA process themselves, using different experts and early case assessment tools will usually provide more accurate conclusions. Your assessment process will depend on your resources, case details, and contacts within your organization, among other factors. Case management software and other tools can help you maintain a thorough paper trail of your care coordination for a much simpler ECA process. That said, software and online assessments are no substitute for advice from a professional legal expert. Key Objectives of Conducting an Early Case Assessment Whether there's potential litigation against you or you're otherwise considering legal action, an early case assessment will help you weigh all relevant details and possible outcomes. In many cases, litigation can be avoided with the appropriate steps. But the wrong actions could cost your organization even more in damages. An ECA helps clear the air so you can make the most informed decision possible. Identify the Key Issues in the Case First and foremost, the ECA process aims to identify and cleanly report all available information for a case. Specifically, it highlights the key concepts that will "hold up" in court, their severity, the parties involved, and other immediately relevant details. By identifying a case's most critical issues early, you can avoid irreversible damage from taking action prematurely. Additionally, if the ECA determines legal action is inevitable, you can compile evidence and a legal team earlier for a more comprehensive defense strategy. Gather and Review Relevant Data Compiling important data early in the process lets you appropriately gauge your entire legal situation, including costs, evidence, custodian names, and relevant medical reports. This is important to avoid potential surprise legal fees later. Additionally, it gives you time to make digital copies of paper documents for easier dispersal later. Using case management software in your social services workflow makes it significantly easier to gather relevant data. These programs automatically compile case files and tasks for a cleaner desktop and paper trail. This software Assess the Risk and Potential Costs of the Case The response to many legal matters ultimately comes down to money, often comparing the costs of settlements, court victories, and litigation losses. Unfortunately, neither of these three standard outcomes can be estimated entirely as additional charges, settlement negotiations, and other factors can complicate matters. ECA aims to estimate the most likely outcomes in each scenario. The most significant costs to consider in early case assessment include: Settlement estimations Legal fees if moving to settle Legal fees if moving to court Damages, claims, and liabilities Filing and court fees Applicable taxes Time lost and other expenses within the organization Risks to reputation In some situations, a business may know it will win its defense in court, but the ECA reveals the combined court fees outweigh the settlement costs. The organization will most likely move to settle.